Mary Maxim Puzzle Club is the best puzzle subscription service for most readers, because it sends two puzzles a month for $19.99 plus $4.99 shipping, with no minimum commitment, while Jiggy Puzzle Club is the best pick for modern art puzzles you plan to frame. The cheapest per-puzzle jigsaw plan here is Buffalo Games at $13 per puzzle when you pay in advance for 6 or 12 months, but it locks you into one brand and offers no month-to-month choice. Completing the Puzzle is the only rental service in this list: you return each puzzle after finishing it, and the 4-puzzle plan works out to less than $11 per puzzle at the $44 monthly price.
A puzzle subscription only works if the pace matches how fast you finish puzzles. One puzzle a month suits a slow evening puzzler, while two or four a month suits a household that finishes a 500-piece puzzle in a weekend. Piece count matters just as much as price: a 300-piece puzzle can take an evening, and a 1000-piece puzzle can take a week. The services below cover jigsaw puzzles you keep, jigsaw puzzles you rent and return, wooden puzzles, and mechanical puzzles, so the right pick depends on the type of puzzle you enjoy most.
On this page
- Comparison table
- 1. Jiggy Puzzle Club
- 2. Mary Maxim Puzzle Club
- 3. Puzzle Warehouse Puzzle of the Month Club
- 4. Buffalo Games Subscription
- 5. White Mountain Puzzle Subscription
- 6. Completing the Puzzle
- 7. Kubiya Games Puzzle Subscription
- 8. Hoefnagel Puzzle Club
- How we chose
- What to check before you buy
- FAQ
- Sources
Best puzzle subscription service: comparison table
Swipe the table sideways on a phone to see every column.
| # | Name | Best for | Starting price | Free plan / trial | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jiggy Puzzle Club | Modern art puzzles to frame | quote only | Not applicable | Visit |
| 2 | Mary Maxim Puzzle Club | Two surprise puzzles a month | $19.99 per month | Not applicable | Visit |
| 3 | Puzzle Warehouse Puzzle of the Month Club | Brand variety with free shipping | $19.99 per month with free shipping | Not applicable | Visit |
| 4 | Buffalo Games Subscription | Lowest per-puzzle price | $78 for 6 months | Not applicable | Visit |
| 5 | White Mountain Puzzle Subscription | Choosing all puzzles in advance | quote only | Not applicable | Visit |
| 6 | Completing the Puzzle | Renting puzzles instead of keeping them | $44 per month | Not applicable | Visit |
| 7 | Kubiya Games Puzzle Subscription | Mechanical puzzles by difficulty | $39.99 per month | Not applicable | Visit |
| 8 | Hoefnagel Puzzle Club | Wooden jigsaw puzzle rentals | $36 per month | Not applicable | Visit |
The 8 best best puzzle subscription services, in detail
Jiggy Puzzle Club
Best for: Modern art puzzles to frame
Jiggy Puzzle Club sends one exclusive 500-piece puzzle each month, and each puzzle features work by an emerging female artist. The puzzle arrives in a reusable drawstring bag and a box printed with the artwork, and each puzzle includes the tools needed to glue it for framing, although glue itself is sold separately. A percentage of each sale goes to the artist behind the design.
- The first order is processed on the day it is placed, and later orders process on the 1st of each month.
- Members can pause or skip a month any time before an order processes, and they can manage billing and shipping details from an online account page.
- The official FAQ page opened for this article does not show a monthly price, so the starting price is listed as quote only.
- Choose Jiggy if you want modern art you can frame, and skip it if you live outside the US or want a choice of piece counts.
Pros
- Exclusive 500-piece puzzle each month
- pause, skip, or cancel before shipping
- early access to new designs
Cons
- Membership is open to domestic US customers only
- glue for framing is sold separately
- monthly puzzles are non-returnable
Mary Maxim Puzzle Club
Best for: Two surprise puzzles a month
Mary Maxim Puzzle Club offers three clubs based on piece count: 300-piece, 500-piece or 550-piece, and 1000-piece. You pick one club, and the Mary Maxim team selects two puzzles for you each month from established manufacturers, including SunsOut. Themes lean toward nostalgic Americana, nature scenes, animals, and seasonal imagery.
- The cost is $19.99 per month plus $4.99 flat shipping, which comes to $24.98 in total per month, and shipping covers the contiguous US only.
- There is no minimum commitment and no cancellation fee, although cancellation is handled by calling customer service rather than through an online acc
- Payment is by credit card only.
- Choose Mary Maxim if you finish puzzles fast and want volume without deciding, and skip it if you want to pick each puzzle yourself.
Pros
- Two puzzles per month for $24.98 in total
- three piece-count clubs to choose from
- no minimum commitment
Cons
- You cannot choose which puzzles arrive
- shipping adds $4.99 to every month
- cancellation is by phone call only
Puzzle Warehouse Puzzle of the Month Club
Best for: Brand variety with free shipping
Puzzle Warehouse is a large online puzzle retailer, and its Puzzle of the Month Club draws from that stock, so a month can bring a puzzle from SunsOut, Buffalo Games, MasterPieces, Cobble Hill, or another manufacturer. That variety is the main reason to pick it: you see different cutting styles and artwork from month to month instead of one brand house style. You choose a preferred piece count of 300, 500, or 1000 pieces when you sign up.
- The cost is $19.99 per month with free shipping, and members also get free shipping on other Puzzle Warehouse orders with no minimum purchase while th
- You can skip months, pause, or cancel through an online account.
- One limit: one puzzle a month is half the volume Mary Maxim sends for a similar base price.
- Choose Puzzle Warehouse if brand variety and free shipping matter more than volume.
Pros
- Puzzles from many brands, including SunsOut and Cobble Hill
- free shipping on subscription orders
- skip months when needed
Cons
- Only one puzzle per month for the same base price as Mary Maxim
- you do not choose the specific puzzle
- theme preferences are not guaranteed
Buffalo Games Subscription
Best for: Lowest per-puzzle price
Buffalo Games makes its own puzzles, and its subscription sends only Buffalo Games puzzles, one per month. At the start of each month you receive an email with three puzzle options and choose which one you want, and if you do not respond within five days you receive the default selection. That monthly choice is rare among jigsaw clubs, and it cuts the risk of receiving a theme you dislike.
- Puzzles ship on the 15th of each month, with shipping included.
- The 300-piece and 500-piece plans cost $78 for 6 months or $156 for 12 months, which works out to $13 per puzzle.
- The 750-piece and 1000-piece plans cost $84 for 6 months or $168 for 12 months, or $14 per puzzle, and the 2000-piece plan costs $96 for 6 months or $
- Choose Buffalo Games if you like the brand and want the lowest per-puzzle price, and skip it if you want brand variety or a short trial.
Pros
- Choose from three puzzle options each month
- $13 per puzzle for the 300-piece and 500-piece plans
- shipping included in the price
Cons
- No month-to-month option, only 6-month or 12-month terms
- only Buffalo Games puzzles are sent
- no option to skip a month
White Mountain Puzzle Subscription
Best for: Choosing all puzzles in advance
White Mountain Puzzles is a New Hampshire company known for nostalgic, Americana-themed artwork, and its subscription works differently from the surprise clubs in this list. Instead of receiving a puzzle chosen for you, you select all your puzzles in advance from the catalog when you sign up. The standard pattern is three puzzles every two months for one year, or 18 puzzles in total, with clubs for 1000-piece puzzles, medium piece counts of 300 and 550 pieces, and a variety piece count with mixed sizes.
- The cost is listed as a 10 percent discount on puzzle prices plus free shipping for the year, and the total varies with the puzzles you choose, so the
- Free shipping applies to all subscription deliveries.
- The trade-off is the one-year commitment and the need to know what you want before the year starts.
- Choose White Mountain if you already know the titles you want, and skip it if you enjoy surprises.
Pros
- You select every puzzle yourself
- free shipping on subscription deliveries
- 10 percent discount on puzzle prices
Cons
- One-year commitment
- no surprise element
- only White Mountain puzzles are sent
Completing the Puzzle
Best for: Renting puzzles instead of keeping them
Completing the Puzzle is a rental service, not a buy-and-keep club. You receive four premium puzzles per month, finish them, and send them back in a reusable bag with a pre-printed return label, and the next four ship after the return is scanned. The catalog covers more than 1,250 puzzles from more than 50 brands, including Galison, Cobble Hill, Eurographics, Eeboo, and Mudpuppy, and new puzzles are added weekly.
- The 4-puzzle monthly plan is $44 per month, with the first month at $33 under a 25 percent first-month offer, and the subscription renews at the full
- A 3-month plan is $116, and a 6-month plan is $230.
- At $44 a month for four puzzles, the cost works out to $11 per puzzle.
- Choose this service if shelf space is short and you finish puzzles fast, and skip it if you want to keep or frame what you build.
Pros
- Four premium puzzles per month
- free shipping both ways
- cancel or pause any time
Cons
- You return every puzzle, so you keep none of them
- 4 puzzles a month can be too many for slow puzzlers
- first month discount ends and the price rises to $44
Kubiya Games Puzzle Subscription
Best for: Mechanical puzzles by difficulty
Kubiya Games ships mechanical puzzles, not jigsaw puzzles, from its Brooklyn studio. Each box holds 1 to 2 handcrafted puzzles, and the three tiers set the difficulty: Player is for beginners, Explorer is for experienced solvers, and Thinker is for solvers who want the hardest mechanical challenges. Boxes can include wooden interlocking puzzles, metal trick-opening puzzles, disentanglement puzzles, and Japanese burr puzzles, with a picture solution guide by QR code in each box.
- The Player, Explorer, and Thinker boxes are each $39.99 per month on a 3-month term, or $119.97 for 3 months, with 6-month and 12-month terms also off
- All subscriptions are settled in full in advance, and once the selected term is complete the subscription simply ends, with no automatic renewal and n
- Boxes ship at the start of each month.
- Choose Kubiya if you want a hands-on mechanical challenge, and skip it if you want flat jigsaw puzzles.
Pros
- Three difficulty tiers, Player, Explorer, and Thinker
- 1 to 2 handcrafted puzzles in each box
- no automatic renewal when the term ends
Cons
- You pay in advance for the full term
- no month-to-month billing choice
- advanced tiers can be too hard for new solvers
Hoefnagel Puzzle Club
Best for: Wooden jigsaw puzzle rentals
Hoefnagel Puzzle Club is a rental library for wooden jigsaw puzzles, run by Wooden Jigsaw Puzzles Club LLC. Members keep a wishlist of puzzle packs, and the club sends packs from that wishlist. Most packs hold two puzzles, although some larger puzzles ship alone.
- When you finish a pack, you ship it directly to another club member who has that pack on their wishlist, using a pre-made label.
- There are no late fees until your membership ends, when you have 30 days to ship out any packs you hold.
- Membership costs $36 monthly, $200 for 6 months, or $360 for 12 months, which the club presents as two months free on the yearly term.
- On top of the membership fee, you pay a flat $12.50 in shipping each time you ship a pack out, while shipping to you is free.
Pros
- Access to around 2,000 wooden puzzles from about 100 makers
- choose packs from your own wishlist
- no late fees while membership is active
Cons
- You pay $12.50 in shipping each time you ship a pack out
- members can wait about a week between packs
- membership fees are not refundable after the first shipment
How we chose
We only included services with a subscription that was still offered on an official page opened on 2026-11-12, and we required a named brand, a clear delivery pattern, and a shown price or a clear reason the price was not shown. Prices and plan limits in this article come from official vendor pricing pages and help pages opened on 2026-11-12, including the Mary Maxim comparison guide, the Completing the Puzzle plan page, the Kubiya Games subscription page, and the Hoefnagel Puzzle Club FAQ. Where an official page showed no single starting price, we wrote quote only instead of using a third-party price. We did not test any tool hands-on. We did not use customer counts, awards, or review scores to rank the services.
What to check before you buy
Check how many puzzles you actually finish in a month before you pick a plan, because a 4-puzzle rental plan is wasted if you finish one puzzle a month. Check the piece count for each club, because most clubs lock you into one count. Check shipping and return costs: Mary Maxim adds $4.99 per month, Hoefnagel adds $12.50 each time you ship a pack out, and Completing the Puzzle includes shipping both ways. Check the commitment: Mary Maxim and Puzzle Warehouse let you cancel any time, while Buffalo Games and White Mountain ask for 6 months to a full year.
| Your pace | Best pick | Monthly cost |
|---|---|---|
| One puzzle a month, any brand | Puzzle Warehouse Puzzle of the Month Club | $19.99 |
| Two puzzles a month, no choosing | Mary Maxim Puzzle Club | $24.98 in total |
| One puzzle a month, lowest per-puzzle price | Buffalo Games Subscription | $13 per puzzle on a 6-month term |
| Four puzzles a month, no storage | Completing the Puzzle | $44 |
| Wooden puzzles, rented | Hoefnagel Puzzle Club | $36 plus $12.50 per pack shipped out |
| Mechanical puzzles | Kubiya Games Puzzle Subscription | $39.99 |
Frequently asked questions
Which puzzle subscription is best for most people?
Mary Maxim Puzzle Club is the best pick for most readers, because it sends two puzzles a month for $19.99 plus $4.99 shipping, with no minimum commitment and a choice of 300-piece, 500-piece, or 1000-piece clubs. The main limit is that you cannot choose which puzzles arrive, so pick Puzzle Warehouse or Buffalo Games if you want more control over each month.
How much does a puzzle subscription cost per month?
Monthly costs in this article run from $19.99 for Puzzle Warehouse and $19.99 plus $4.99 shipping for Mary Maxim, through $36 for Hoefnagel Puzzle Club and $39.99 for Kubiya Games, to $44 for the 4-puzzle Completing the Puzzle plan. Buffalo Games works out to $13 per puzzle on a 6-month term, and Jiggy and White Mountain show no single starting price on their official pages.
Is a puzzle rental subscription better than buying puzzles?
A rental plan is better if shelf space is short and you finish puzzles fast, because Completing the Puzzle sends four puzzles a month for $44 and Hoefnagel gives access to around 2,000 wooden puzzles for $36 a month. Buying is better if you want to keep or frame finished puzzles, because rental puzzles must be returned after you finish them.
Which puzzle subscription lets me choose my puzzles?
Buffalo Games lets you choose from three puzzle options each month, and White Mountain lets you select all 18 puzzles for the year in advance. Hoefnagel lets you build a wishlist and receive packs from it, while Mary Maxim and Puzzle Warehouse select the puzzles for you, so the surprise clubs suit readers who enjoy not deciding.
Can I cancel a puzzle subscription any time?
Mary Maxim, Puzzle Warehouse, and Completing the Puzzle allow cancellation any time, although Mary Maxim cancellation is handled by phone call. Buffalo Games asks you to pay in advance for 6 or 12 months, White Mountain asks for a one-year commitment, and Kubiya subscriptions end when the term you chose is complete, with no automatic renewal.
Sources
- https://jiggypuzzles.com/
- https://jiggypuzzles.com/pages/faq
- https://www.marymaxim.com/
- https://www.marymaxim.com/blogs/puzzles/puzzle-subscription-boxes-a-complete-comparison-guide
- https://www.puzzlewarehouse.com/
- https://www.buffalogames.com/
- https://www.whitemountainpuzzles.com/
- https://www.completingthepuzzle.com/
- https://www.completingthepuzzle.com/4-puzzle/upgrade-everyday
- https://kubiyagames.com/
- https://kubiyagames.com/pages/puzzle-subscription
- https://www.woodenjigsawpuzzles.com/
- https://www.woodenjigsawpuzzles.com/faq.html
Prices and features were read on each company’s own website in November 2026. They change often, so confirm the current offer on the official site before you sign up or buy.